Reading notesMichele Pasin / Sept–Nov 2026

Quiver, don't Quake

Notes on Quiver, don't Quake: How Creativity Can Embrace AI by Nadim Sadek (Mensch, 2025). His site is thepanthropic.ai. What the book argues, and the evidence on either side.

Same tremor, read as excitement
Quotes / from the book

Inspiring quotes

Sadek at his most quotable, in the order they appear in the book.

Part 1 / nine threads

Themes

Nine threads that run through the book. Sadek shows what the book says about each one, and where. Context has the counterpoints, the evidence and links to background reading. Switch the layers on and off.

Part 2 / chapter 9

Critics worth reading

Chapter 9 sets out the case against AI creativity. This is a selection of the critics it discusses, chosen because they're interesting rather than to be complete. Pick one to see the critique, Sadek's reply and where to read more.

Part 3 / the title, read two ways

Quiver or quake?

The title describes one tremor that you can read as excitement or as fear. Slide towards quiver for the book's reading of each topic, and towards quake for the counter-reading from critics and research. Hover over a card, or tap it, to flip just that one.

Same tremor, read as excitement
Coda / my take

My take

This was an inspiring read. Most of what I read about AI and creativity is either hype or alarm. Sadek is optimistic without being naive: he gives a whole interlude to why we should quake, and a chapter to his critics. What stays with me is the reframe in the title, the same tremor read as excitement instead of fear, and the practical advice that goes with it: treat AI as a partner in a conversation rather than a vending machine, ask for fifty ideas and have the confidence to discard forty-nine, and defend your why. It made me want to make things, which is more than most books on AI do.

In a world of frictionless creation, the scarce thing is human taste in service of a purpose, and taste is formed by exactly the friction AI removes.

That's my working thesis after reading Sadek. I agree with him that once generating things is cheap, selection and taste are what count. Where I part ways is on where taste comes from. Juniors learn it doing routine work, musicians learn it at the instrument, and those are the parts AI is best at taking away. The value of the Panthropic is real, but the "someone" in the conversation is you.

Sadek gives a whole chapter to his critics and answers most of them. Two get only a general closing: Jaron Lanier on provenance and Cory Doctorow on attention. They're also the two closest to my own work, and where I think there's more to say than the book does.